So if Harry died, his soul would be fine, and the part of Voldemort's soul would not die because it is contained in Harry's soul, not his body. He gripped the fang that was spreading poison through his body and wrenched it out of his arm. 4 . ** Use in-universe knowledge, rules, and common sense to answer the questions. So, in conclusion, the reason the last (Harry) Horcrux was not destroyed from Basilisk bite was because the Phoenix tears stopped the venom spread and healed the damage before the Horcrux vessel (Harry) was completely destroyed. He is NOT like other horcruxes. Why is the federal judiciary of the United States divided into circuits? There was a long, dreadful, piercing scream. Well, I always thought that Harry survived in the forest because he was having all the three deathly hallows with him at that time. Hey everyoneWelcome to another installment of Harry Potter Theory. Browse other questions tagged, Start here for a quick overview of the site, Detailed answers to any questions you might have, Discuss the workings and policies of this site, Learn more about Stack Overflow the company. It copied the destructive force of the venom. [4], Ron Weasley used the Sword of Gryffindor to destroy Salazar Slytherin's Locket. :). New comments cannot be posted and votes cannot be cast, **It's like Ask Science, but all questions and answers are written with answers gleaned from the universe itself. Appropriate translation of "puer territus pedes nudos aspicit"? He dies, well, almost. :). The only way to destroy a Horcrux, as Hermione tells us, is to put it beyond magical repair. And thank you for giving me a chance to say that because people have argued that quite a lot. Didn't quite get that. Vote on future topics for SFF topic challenges! Harry was exceptionally fortunate Once the soul piece is destroyed, even if the object comes into contact with phoenix tears, itd be too late because the soul piece within it would already have been destroyed. So rather than "beyond magical repair", it would be more accurate to think of the criterion for destroying a Horcrux as "beyond the ability of (present-day) wizardry to repair." How does the Chameleon's Arcane/Divine focus interact with magic item crafting? How to set a newcommand to be incompressible by justification? Are there breakers which can be triggered by an external signal and have to be reset by hand? That can be the cursed fire Goyle (I think it was Goyle) used in the room of requirement, the killing curse or Basilisk venom. Now that's an interesting question.. +1 -- I can see some possibilities, but I hope someone comes up with something conclusive and sourced. Why didn't Tupolev destroy the incoming torpedo? Ink spurted out of the diary in torrents, streaming over Harry's hands, flooding the floor. Why do American universities have so many general education courses? Making statements based on opinion; back them up with references or personal experience. But if you can't answer it, who (other than JKR) can? How to smoothen the round border of a created buffer to make it look more natural? First of all forgive me if I spelt anything wrong. Penrose diagram of hypothetical astrophysical white hole. If basilisk venom is strong enough to destroy Horcruxes, and Harry got bitten by a Basilisk in the Chamber of Secrets, why wasn't the horcrux Press J to jump to the feed. Help us identify new roles for community members. What do you think? These come together with something Hermione says in Deathly Hallows: "Look, if I picked up a sword right now, Ron, and ran you through with it, I wouldn't damage your soul at all.whatever happens to your body, your soul will survive, untouched," said Hermione. What can destroy a Horcrux? Can it be dripped on? 'It has to be something so destructive that the Horcrux can't repair itself. How to smoothen the round border of a created buffer to make it look more natural. Due to Harry Potter killing the Serpent of Slytherin with it, the sword was imbued with Basilisk venom and could destroy Horcruxes. it was irreparable within a short period of time. Why is Basilisk venom The only thing that can destroy a Horcrux? Perhaps it could be saved by Phoenix tears, but it could not save itself. Seriously, did the bite kill Harry or just come close to killing him? Was Lucius Malfoy about to use the killing curse on Harry? The best answers are voted up and rise to the top, Not the answer you're looking for? JK Rowling at Carnegie Hall 10.20.07. I think, it should override all other speculations or indirect reference logics. After being healed, Harry took the fang and stabbed Riddle's diary, destroying that Horcrux beyond magical repair. J.K. Rowling has addressed this multiple times, but the clearest explanation shes given of why the basilisk bite didnt kill the piece of soul in Harry is perhaps in this interview. It is because Harry is a living being. Effect of coal and natural gas burning on particulate matter pollution. Is it cheating if the proctor gives a student the answer key by mistake and the student doesn't report it? Did some part of Voldemort's soul get stuck in Harry Potter's body in Sorcerer's Stone? Community content is available under. This means that it never required cleaning. SU: So, can I ask this? Name of a play about the morality of prostitution (kind of). NOTE: I've read the HP Wiki's entry on Horcruxes; however, I find the HP Wiki to be inconsistent in its accuracy, so I'm hesitant to accept the Wiki's explanation on the matter. Why can only basilisk venom destroy Horcruxes? Basilisk venom is a method for destroying Horcruxes because once it takes effect, it renders the object irreparable, and the only chance for possibly repairing it is immediately putting phoenix tears on it. Is this an at-all realistic configuration for a DHC-2 Beaver? Their venom also has powerful dark magic. What is this fallacy: Perfection is impossible, therefore imperfection should be overlooked. Harry was bitten by a Basilisk - how is he still a Horcrux? Incidentally it does not seem to be common knowledge what comes after death, though several characters have had insight into it (the priori incantatem incident, Harry's interaction with the Veil in the Department of Mysteries) and it seems that consciousness persists after death in the HP world, but that it is apparently freed from the body for a destination unknown. rev2022.12.9.43105. Because Harry had stabbed the Basilisk with the sword, it was imbued with Basilisk venom and was therefore able to destroy Horcruxes and poison opponents that it cut through as well. Harry was healed by Fawkes. The point is that Basilisk venom is so destructive that there's only one way to repair the damage it causes. Hence, if you stab a Horcrux with something impregnated with Basilisk venom and you don't put any Phoenix tears on it very quickly, it is going to be destroyed. Yes, excellent question. Manage all your favorite fandoms in one place! I established early in the book, Hermione says that you destroy a Horcrux by using something so powerful that there's no remedy. The creator of a Horcrux chooses to cast many additional spells on the Horcrux, in addition to the Horcrux-creating spell, to give it additional safeguards and protections. Basilisk Venom destroyed the ring, locket, and Nagini. But he knew it was too late. Everything else was given the chance to die from whatever destroyed it, but Harry was saved from death by the phoenix tears. When J.K. Rowling explains why being poisoned with basilisk venom didnt kill the soul piece in Harry, she explains that Harry was mended before he was destroyed, and that phoenix tears have to be administered immediately or the basilisk venom makes the object irreparable, presumably even by phoenix tears. central limit theorem replacing radical n with n. Why is the federal judiciary of the United States divided into circuits? Therefore, it's likely that the reason why a Horcrux is mostly indestructible is merely because it is enchanted to be so by its creator. In this video, we'll be discussing a moment in the series when Harry and the horcrux insid. But she does say there is a remedy for basilisk poison but of course it has to be administered immediately and when they stab the cup later - boy I'm really blowing this for anyone who hasn't finished the book - there's Fawkes, is my answer. As goblin's silver, it imbibed only substances which strengthened it, which could then be used against enemies. The rubber protection cover does not pass through the hole in the rim. I'm surprised that no one has pointed out that perhaps all the other horcrux souls left our knowledge of them, but may also have gone to "limbo" just as the one in Harry did. harry did not die, and was healed by something stronger than basilisk poison, so the horcrux remained. Press question mark to learn the rest of the keyboard shortcuts Yes, I know Fawkes quite quickly healed the bite wound with his phoenix tears, but when Harry used the basilisk fang to destroy Tom Riddle's diary the destruction of that Horcrux was immediate. JK Rowling has actually addressed this very subject, at Carnegie Hall in 2007: Question: When Harry was stabbed by a basilisk in the Chamber of Secrets, So before he could be destroyed without repair, rev2022.12.9.43105. Harry may have had a scar (I agree with you -- he should have one from the Basilisk bite), but the books don't say. What makes a Horcrux object (almost) indestructible? Why didn't the Basilisk's bite destroy the Horcrux? Why does the USA not have a constitutional court? When Harry was stabbed by a basilisk in the Chamber of Secrets, since he was a Horcrux, shouldn't it have been destroyed then? The Horcrux would not be able to repair itself if it were damaged by Basilisk venom and would quickly perish. The best answers are voted up and rise to the top, Not the answer you're looking for? Basilisk venom is a method for destroying Horcruxes because once it takes effect, it renders the object irreparable, and the only chance for possibly repairing it is immediately putting phoenix tears on it. By clicking Post Your Answer, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy. How many transistors at minimum do you need to build a general-purpose computer? Following this logic, if Harry had died from the Basilisk bite, then the Horcrux would have been destroyed (but that didn't happen). There are two ways to destroy a Horcrux: One, for the ine who created it to deeply regret what they did (doesn't apply here) or two: Hit it with something powerful that irrepairably damages it. Why Didn't the Basilisk Bite in Chamber of Secrets Destroy the Horcrux? Take your time. Examples of frauds discovered because someone tried to mimic a random sequence. But why can Basalisk venom destroy the Horcrux's? Share. @marcellothearcane harry might have died from his skull being crushed if the basilisk bit his head. In the forest, Harry wasn't protected by his mother's love anymore because Voldemort had used Harry's blood to regenerate. Can a prospective pilot be negated their certification because of too big/small hands. Is it correct to say "The glue on the back of the sticker is dying down so I can not stick the sticker to the wall"? Connecting three parallel LED strips to the same power supply. So a lot of people asked, and I think Ive answered this since, but a lot of people immediately said, having finished Hallows, (gasps) But then, that means in Chamber of Secrets, when he was pierced by the basilisk (SU: Oh, right) but no, no, no, no, he didnt die! Maybe the logic works that his body can last longer with the poison than a book, locket, cup or ring and theoretically if a phoenix had cried on those immediately after being stabbed they would have resurrected/been ok and the Horcrux would still function/exist. Why can basilisk venom destroy Horcruxes? Harry survived getting bit by a basilisk because he had on hand the one cure for basilisk venom: phoenix tears. @Edlothiad: I agree this should have citations (I unfortunately am not near the books now), but I'm confused by you re-stating what I thought I said in the post. We just aren't told this part because it is in "the other world" one enters after death. It only takes a minute to sign up. Speculation ahead; the reason WHY in the case of an animal, death is required rather than just damage, is very likely due to the Horcrux not being bonded to the entire body (and thus vulnerable to damage at any point), but to the brain. [3], Basilisk venom was one of the few poisons that was not curable by bezoars. and i will give it: . Appealing a verdict due to the lawyers being incompetent and or failing to follow instructions? Harry was exceptionally fortunate in that he had Fawkes. He wasn't made intentionally. The only way to destroy a Horcrux, as Hermione tells us, is to put it beyond magical repair. (That is, Hermione is implicitly using a wizard-centric view of "magical repair".). The sword is goblin made, and copies powers. I remember Tom Riddle talking about how when in the body it kills quickly, but thats it, it dosent seem magical its just venom from a big bad snake, why cant I got find the lowest of the venomous snakes and use its blood to destroy the Horcruxs? Fawkes was there for what, the cup? [Captain America: the First Avenger] Why did SHIELD use [Men in Black] In first movie we've seen that alien [Marvel] Why does Punisher have such immense respect for [Toy Story 2] Did Woody belong to Andys dad? Are there conservative socialists in the US? Get started today with $75 off by using code SCB at http://candidco.com/SCBToday J dives into the Wizarding World of Harry Potter to determine why the Basili. Thus the destruction of the horcruxes's vessel implies Harry's death as well. The best illustration of that is in the movie, when the diary needs to be stabbed several times by the Basilisk fang in order to completely destroy the soul fragment manifesting itself as Riddle. By clicking Accept all cookies, you agree Stack Exchange can store cookies on your device and disclose information in accordance with our Cookie Policy. If you don't think it should have posted here you can always DV. This is kind of a random question, but if Harry had this Horcrux in him, sort of, would he actually have died, say, when the dragon could have killed him, or when he was falling during Quiddich, or anything? In case of Basilisk bite, Harry was NOT destroyed completely. I have been told that Harry wasn't a normal Horcrux, as he wasn't made intentionaly, so as he is not a normal Horcrux, the destruction of the Horcrux inside would be different. From a JKR interview1: I think, by definition, a Horcrux has to be made intentionally. To subscribe to this RSS feed, copy and paste this URL into your RSS reader. Could the Sword of Gryffindor have destroyed a horcrux before it absorbed the Basilisk Venom. How can I fix it? As it turns out, Fawkes not only saved Harry but also the part of Voldemort's soul living in him. Most people would have probably died quicker, but he did have Lily's protection anyway, so that helped ward off the venom for a little while. Logically, the way to destroy a piece of soul attached to to another one is to destroy the host soul beyond magical repair with something like Avada Kedavra. The 'Love Protection' only covers Harry and not the Horcrux. There's no spell to reverse death. It can't exist without it." So before he could be destroyed without repair, which is what is necessary to destroy a horcrux, he was mended. [1] This powerful venom was one of the few substances known to be capable of destroying Horcruxes, causing them fatal damage that could not be repaired. But as the sword was infused with basilisk venom, perhaps she would have died a slow death. Could he actually have died? Why is Singapore considered to be a dictatorial regime and a multi-party democracy at the same time? He didnt die. To subscribe to this RSS feed, copy and paste this URL into your RSS reader. How did muzzle-loaded rifled artillery solve the problems of the hand-held rifle? Wizards evidently cannot just conjure up phoenix tears, and the same restriction must also apply to Horcruxes. How does legislative oversight work in Switzerland when there is technically no "opposition" in parliament? And thank you for giving me a chance to say that because people have argued that quite a lot. The best answers are voted up and rise to the top, Not the answer you're looking for? How can I use a VPN to access a Russian website that is banned in the EU? Do you have any references to back this up? rev2022.12.9.43105. As we know from the end of the book, the wand won't betray is rightful master, so when Voldemort used it on Harry in the forest, I believe the wand detected 2 targets, it's master, which it wouldn't harm, and the shard of Voldemort's soul, so it targeted the shard directly. [ Harry] didn't have curses upon him that the other Horcruxes had. His body has got to be irreparably damaged. As explained in the books, a Horcrux needs to be damaged beyond magical repair. Harry thus didn't actually die before Fawkes healed him, so the container of the horcrux was preserved. At what point in the prequels is it revealed that Palpatine is Darth Sidious? The truth is Rowling didnt plan Harry being a Horucrux when she wrote the second book. and to me they are a really nice visual representation of what JKR's universe might look like when brought to life. Nice answer. The Sword of Gryffindor was useful in destroying Horcruxes because it was imbued with Basilisk Venom when Harry stabbed the monstrous snake in the Chamber of Secrets. That tethering is broken when Horcrux is destroyed completely. administered immediately and when they stab the cup later boy Im But she does say there is a remedy for basilisk poison but of course it has to be administered immediately and when they stab the cup later - boy I'm really blowing this for anyone who hasn't finished the book - there's Fawkes, is my answer. It takes way too much magic and would leave me exhausted, and most probably passed out for a few days. JKR: Well, youve got- if his body had been irreparably destroyed. All the answers above use well grounded information that are not based on "Harry being different" whatsoever. Is there a logical/canon-based explanation for why the fragment of Voldemort's soul residing in Harry wasn't destroyed upon Harry being bitten by the basilisk? Why can a Basilisk fang kill a Horcrux? So thats not going to drive out this piece of soul. Welcome to scifi.stackexchange! Harry Potter and Hermione Granger both used the fangs of Salazar Slytherin's Basilisk to destroy Tom Riddle's Diary and Helga Hufflepuff's Cup, respectively. By clicking Accept all cookies, you agree Stack Exchange can store cookies on your device and disclose information in accordance with our Cookie Policy. [1], After being healed, Harry took the fang and stabbed Riddle's diary, destroying that Horcrux beyond magical repair. So we now that even if Harry had died his soul remained there. Can virent/viret mean "green" in an adjectival sense? its the only physical protection the horcrux has. What gave Harry Potter the idea of writing in Tom Riddle's diary? I established early in the book, Hermione says that you destroy a Horcrux by using something so powerful that there's no remedy. Is the EU Border Guard Agency able to tell Russian passports issued in Ukraine or Georgia from the legitimate ones? After being healed, Harry took the fang and stabbed Riddle's diary, destroying that Horcrux beyond magical repair. because people have argued that quite a lot. Why didn't the basilisk bite in Chamber of Secrets destroy the Horcrux? Yes, it has to be destructive enough that the horcrux can't repair itself; the reason the horcrux can repair itself is because it is enchanted to do so, and therefore the horcrux can't do magic that it is impossible for a witch or wizard to enchant an object to be able to do. I agree with you about Nagini -- if she had been merely injured by the Sword of Gryffindor, I don't think she would have been destroyed right away. To me, there is absolutely no indication of an "immediate" destruction in many of the cases of the horcruxes. See the answers to What makes a Horcrux object (almost) indestructible? I'm in no hurry.The memory of Tom Riddle awaiting Harry Potter's death from Basilisk venom in the Chamber of Secrets, In 1993, Harry Potter stabbed the roof of the Basilisk's mouth with the Sword of Gryffindor and ended up getting a fang splintered into his arm. But she does say there is a remedy for basilisk poison but of course it has to be administered immediately and when they stab the cup later - boy I'm really blowing this for anyone who hasn't finished the book - there's Fawkes, is my answer. Please try to reduce the use of answers to the answers backed with references, if there's an information deemed useful to the question or one answer, use the comment section below. The diadem seems to have been destroyed by Fiendfyre immediately as well, as when Harry examined it outside the Room of Requirement it was already leaking a blood-like substance, and then it cracked in half. Harry's wand fell to the floor with a clatter and there was silence. Why did Harry let Ron destroy the locket horcrux? Create an account to follow your favorite communities and start taking part in conversations. Once phoenix tears are not administered in a short period of time, the damage will be done and the Horcrux object will be destroyed irreparably. #pleaseneveraskmethatoneagain. Basilisks have powerful dark magic, as shown by their paralytic effect. It doesn't have to be a Basilisk fang. I also consider JKR interviews, JKR.com, and Pottermore to include canon proper information. Moreover, the fact that the fang was struck "through the heart" of the book may be significant - it's possible that simply ripping one page with a fang or scratching a corner would have done some damage but not destroyed the Horcrux outright. Hermione was perplexed as to why he had not yet destroyed the soul piece. @Arcturus Dean Granger Hello and welcome to this website. This as of now is pure speculation and has no support from canon works. @Slytherincess - Because I thought it would be nice to have them all together in a single answer. Harry is not a Horcrux because in Horcruxes, the little piece of soul in a Horcrux is attached to the physical object. is a remedy for basilisk poison but of course it has to be Press question mark to learn the rest of the keyboard shortcuts, I would not mind you in my head, if you were not so clearly mad. 01.21.12 I have found the answer to this question from J.K. Rowling herself: Q: When Harry was stabbed by a basilisk in the Chamber of Secrets, since he was a Horcrux, shouldn't it have been destroyed then? I had hesitation to use the movie as an example, but since there are no 100% clear canon rules I'm aware of ala LucasVerse, I decided to include both - one for "books are more canon" crowd, one for "both are OK, and movie version is a better example". in that he had Fawkes. As the title asks, why didn't the basilisk bite received in the Chamber of Secrets destroy the Horcrux inside the bitten person? Why did Dumbledore tell Harry there were 6 Horcruxes when he already knew Harry was a horcrux? [5], In 1998, during the Battle of Hogwarts, Ron and Hermione went down to the Chamber of Secrets and destroyed Helga Hufflepuff's Cup with a Basilisk fang. Basilisk venom is a method for destroying Horcruxes because once it takes effect, it renders the object irreparable, and the only chance for possibly repairing it is immediately putting phoenix tears on it. Oh, that's very interesting -- what would happen if phoenix tears were applied to a mortally wounded Horcrux? He wasn't made intentionally. :). (JN: Yeah) That was stated right in the beginning with the Horcrux, the receptacle has got to be destroyed. Why does my stock Samsung Galaxy phone/tablet lack some features compared to other Samsung Galaxy models? Basilisk venom isn't capable of destroying Horcruxes because of any specific anti-Horcrux properties. He is, ^ Confirming what I said above, to quote the book - > ", @MycrofD She just summarized her answer, After expressed her concerns about people haven't finished reading yet. Heck, there are people who have. I can't do the killing curse yet. Due to gum disease, without a tooth cleaning for over a thousand years, this basilisk's incisors were rotting and very little of its poison was released. Asking for help, clarification, or responding to other answers. [1][2], The venom's potency was apparently extremely long-lasting, as Hermione Granger was able to use the venom from the fang of a Basilisk that was dead for nearly five years. Who was killed to make Nagini a Horcrux (Frank Bryce or Bertha Jorkins)? It only takes a minute to sign up. By clicking Accept all cookies, you agree Stack Exchange can store cookies on your device and disclose information in accordance with our Cookie Policy. Being poisoned* does not mean instant death, so if you consume the antidote, the Horcrux survives. Should I give a brutally honest feedback on course evaluations? That is magical repair. Movies & TV Stack Exchange is a question and answer site for movie and TV enthusiasts. Perhaps the love protecting Harry countered the venom until Fawkes turned up. How come when Harry gets bitten by the Basilisk in Chamber of Secrets that doesn't destroy the Horcrux in him? Why does Harry say that there is only one Horcrux left, after only having destroyed 4? The basilisk's poison was strong enough to destroy a horcrux, making fans wonder why the one in Harry didn't die when he was bitten by the giant serpent. Had he died, the Horcrux would indeed have been destroyed. Site design / logo 2022 Stack Exchange Inc; user contributions licensed under CC BY-SA. Was the order of destruction of the Horcruxes a coincidence? Given that the only antidote to basilisk venom is phoenix tears, a horcrux can't repair itself. Why didn't Harry Potter die from the basilisk venom in COS? How does the Basilisk roam around Hogwarts? His body wasnt destroyed! Is there a higher analog of "category with all same side inverses is a groupoid"? When Ron hit the locket with the Sword of Gryffindor, it was destroyed immediately. #pleaseneveraskmethatoneagain J.K. Rowling (@jk_rowling) February 6, 2015, That citation should have been in your answer to begin with (and not as a comment). - Siamore Apr 24, 2013 at 10:39 2 did anything serious ever run on the speccy? @Himarm - I think this has been established for almost three years by now. A Horcrux can be destroyed with Basilisk Venom, Fiendfyre, or the Killing Curse. J. K. Rowling recently answered it on Twitter: @llamaofthelab The Horcrux-receptacle has to be destroyed BEYOND REPAIR, so Harry would need to have DIED. The venom never reached there because of the phoenix tear which also healed his arm which was probably mostly destroyed by then. In HP2 he stabs the diary with the fang, then the sword is used to destroy the rest because it has the venom inside it, how does it apply to the destruction? I've never heard of regret destroying a horcrux, is that word of God? Browse other questions tagged, Start here for a quick overview of the site, Detailed answers to any questions you might have, Discuss the workings and policies of this site, Learn more about Stack Overflow the company. The methods to destroy them include the killing curse, Fiendfyre and basilisk venom. Connect and share knowledge within a single location that is structured and easy to search. MOSFET is getting very hot at high frequency PWM, Sed based on 2 words, then replace whole line with variable. To subscribe to this RSS feed, copy and paste this URL into your RSS reader. Stack Exchange network consists of 181 Q&A communities including Stack Overflow, the largest, most trusted online community for developers to learn, share their knowledge, and build their careers. 'when they stab the CUP later..there's FAWKES..' Sorry. The reason Gryffindor's sword was capable of destroying a horcrux was, that it absorbed Basilisk venom back in book two. Is there any reason on passenger airliners not to have a physical lock between throttles? Basilisk venom was extremely powerful, and could kill a person within a little more than a minute at best, making the person drowsy and blurry-visioned before they died. Even as he dropped the fang and watched his own blood soaking his robes, his vision went foggy. As everyone has said, it's likely because Harry did not die when when he was bitten by the basilisk. which is what is necessary to destroy a horcrux, he was mended. Because Harry had stabbed the Basilisk with the sword, it was imbued . Because Harry had stabbed the Basilisk with the sword, it was imbued with Basilisk venom and was therefore able to destroy Horcruxes and poison opponents that it cut through as well. Would Phoenix Ashes Have Magical or Healing Properties? Fawkes, is my answer. He didn't die from the basilisk because it would still take a moment for the venom to reach his heart, and the horcrux was in his soul. JKR: I have been asked that a lot. plot-explanation. Thats of course not something a Horcrux can do itself, despite their protective enchantments, so once its infected with basilisk venom, its unlikely itd be cured in time to save the soul piece. - J.K. Rowling at Carnegie Hall (October 20, 2007). Basilisk venom only has one antidote, and it's incredibly rare -', Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows - p.90 - Bloomsbury - chapter 6, The Ghoul in Pyjamas. Basilisk venom just so happens to be one of the few substances destructive enough to overcome a Horcrux's magical resilience. Why can Horcruxes only be destroyed by basilisk venom? Tom Riddle described the venom as being able to kill Harry in a little more than a minute, though Fawkes's tears healed Harry's arm and cleansed the poison. Though phoenix tears are a cure for the damage done by basilisk venom, the basilisk venom will still do irreparable damage if not healed quickly by phoenix tears. The stuff is obscenely poisonous, to the point where the only antidote is Phoenix tears. If Basilisk venom can destroy a Horcrux and Harry was a Horcrux, why didn't it destroy Harry in the chamber of secrets when it bit him? White-hot pain was spreading slowly and steadily from the wound. There are two ways to destroy a Horcrux: One, for the ine who created it to deeply regret what they did (doesn't apply here) or two: Hit it with something powerful that irrepairably damages it. The fragment of soul inside it depends on its container, it's enchanted body, for survival. 11. The basilisk didn't bite destroy the horcrux because Harry didn't die from it? And thank you for giving me a chance to say that Secondly, the only way to destroy a piece of soul latched onto a physical object, or a Horcrux, is to put it beyond magical repair. One possible theory for this could be that a horcrux can only be destroyed by the ones who created it or the things used to create it. Why is it bonded with the brain? But you're right -- it's clear from the paragraph you quoted from the book. Or as **fanlore.org** calls it [Watsonian, not a Doylist point of view](http://fanlore.org/wiki/Watsonian_vs._Doylist). The killing curse and Gryffindor's sword are the only other known ways of destroying the horcruxes the killing curse only working when the piece of soul is inside another person i.e Harry. Why wasnt the Horcrux inside Harry destroyed when he was bitten by the Basilisk in Harry Potter and the Chamber of Secrets? CGAC2022 Day 10: Help Santa sort presents! As goblin's silver, it imbibed only substances which strengthened it, which could then be used against enemies. So whatever happens to Harry's body will not harm the bit of Voldemort's soul in any way. [1] This powerful venom was one of the few substances known to be capable of destroying Horcruxes, causing them fatal damage that could not be repaired. He is special. JK Rowling: I have been asked that a lot. As Hermione says in book 7: "Look, if I picked up a sword right now, Ron, and ran you through with it, I wouldn't damage your soul at all." QGIS expression not working in categorized symbology. Does a 120cc engine burn 120cc of fuel a minute? That's all of the Horcruxes except the diadem. Especially given the canon answer makes it abundantly clear that it has to be destructive enough that the horcrux can't repair itself. Although the destruction of the ring occurred off-page, Dumbledore used the Sword of Gryffindor to destroy it, so presumably, like the locket, it was gone right away. J.K. Rowling: I have been asked that a lot. December 2022 Topic Challenge: Trudi Canavan, Help us identify new roles for community members, Latest Blog Post: Firefly episodes ranked best to worst. What did Voldemort look like before he killed the Potters? How to connect 2 VMware instance running on same Linux host machine via emulated ethernet cable (accessible via mac address)? - J.K. Rowling at Carnegie Hall (October 20, 2007). So before he could be destroyed without repair, which is what is necessary to destroy a horcrux, he was mended. Fawkes healed Harry's wound with its tears, and it also healed the horcrux inside of . The cup, the locket, Nagini, the ring, and the diary are all destroyed by a sword or fang covered in basilisk venom. I think it is because Harry didn't die from it. J.K. Rowling: The Horcrux-receptacle has to be destroyed BEYOND REPAIR, so Harry would need to have DIED. the-chamber-of-secrets. Counterexamples to differentiation under integral sign, revisited. How do I tell if this single climbing rope is still safe for use? [2] And we know from Dumbledore, also in 7, that "a fragment of Voldemort's soul was blasted apart from the whole, and latched itself onto the only living soul left in that collapsing building." @Slytherincess - "perhaps she would have died a slow death" - quite likely. The Sword of Gryffindor was useful in destroying Horcruxes because it was imbued with Basilisk Venom when Harry stabbed the monstrous snake in the Chamber of Secrets. "But it's the other way round with a Horcrux.". View complete answer on scifi.stackexchange.com Why can't Harry destroy the Horcrux? Where does the idea of selling dragon parts come from? Basilisk venom is a method for destroying Horcruxes because once it takes effect, it renders the object irreparable, and the only chance for possibly repairing it is immediately putting phoenix tears on it. the answer: jk Rowling recently explained this- the object holding the horcrux has to be totally destroyed. The damage done by basilisk venom apparently cannot be repaired effectively with any known spell, so a Horcrux creator cannot enchant the Horcrux to be immune to Basilisk venom. Connect and share knowledge within a single location that is structured and easy to search. Sorry if I sound frustrated, but occasionally - PotterCast (Dec 23, 2007). For me, the movies and the books are just disparate enough that I err on the side of the books. My only niggle with your answer is that I don't consider the movies to be canon proper. View complete answer on scifi.stackexchange.com All Ways to Destroy a HORCRUX - Harry Potter Explained Can a Dementor destroy a Horcrux? How is the merkle root verified if the mempools may be different? Should teachers encourage good students to help weaker ones? Harry Potter and the Order of the Phoenix, Harry Potter Page to Screen: The Complete Filmmaking Journey, LEGO Harry Potter: Building the Magical World, LEGO Harry Potter: Characters of the Magical World, Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows: Part 1, Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows: Part 2, Fantastic Beasts: The Crimes of Grindelwald, Fantastic Beasts: The Secrets of Dumbledore, Magic Beyond Words: The J.K. Rowling Story, Fantastic Beasts: Cases from the Wizarding World, Creator: Harry Potter and the Chamber of Secrets. He got a bit poisoned, and then he got the antidote, immediately. really blowing this for anyone who hasnt finished the book theres How is a Basilisk fang able to destroy Horcruxes? @MandeepJain he dropped the stone, so didn't have that (but I suppose he was still the 'owner', since it wasn't taken from him), A great answer! A Horcrux can only be destroyed if its container is damaged beyond repair. I was. Could Fawkes's Tears Have Healed Tom Riddle's Diary. [1] Because Harry had stabbed the Basilisk with the sword, it was imbued with Basilisk venom and was therefore able to destroy Horcruxes and poison opponents that it cut through as well. It can be plausibly theorized that, had the Sword of Gryffindor merely wounded/scratched Nagini, that Horcrux would also not be instantaneously destroyed. Why does the distance from light to subject affect exposure (inverse square law) while from subject to lens does not? Why is this usage of "I've to work" so awkward? So where is the error here? [2] It only had one known antidote: phoenix tears, which happened to be very rare, decreasing the venom's deadliness. Thanks for contributing an answer to Science Fiction & Fantasy Stack Exchange! In the HP universe, Decartes' dualism seems to be a reality. Did neanderthals need vitamin C from the diet? Basilisk venom is a method for destroying Horcruxes because once it takes effect, it renders the object irreparable, and the only chance for possibly repairing it is immediately putting phoenix tears on it. something so powerful that theres no remedy. Should teachers encourage good students to help weaker ones? This is the first time JKR makes no sense to me at all. I established early in the book, Hermione says that you destroy a Horcrux by using something so powerful that there's no remedy. PotterCast Interviews J.K. Rowling, part one, December 2022 Topic Challenge: Trudi Canavan, Help us identify new roles for community members, Latest Blog Post: Firefly episodes ranked best to worst. As the venom (from the fang) destroyed Riddle's book, why didn't it destroy first the Last Horcrux, within Harry? It is implied that sentience lies within the soul, with the brain merely being a vessel. Stack Exchange network consists of 181 Q&A communities including Stack Overflow, the largest, most trusted online community for developers to learn, share their knowledge, and build their careers. You'll notice that I asked this question five years ago, in 2012, which was a time when the question wasn't overly asked. And that's with Phoenix tears. This was only achievable as basilisk venom was an extremely destructive substance capable of destroying Horcruxes. TypeError: unsupported operand type(s) for *: 'IntVar' and 'float'. Horcrux got stabbed by a basilisk fang, so the poison did its work and After being healed, Harry took the fang and stabbed Riddle's diary, destroying that Horcrux beyond magical repair. Voldemort tried killing Harry in the forest with the Elder Wand. I'd prefer an explanation constructed from information in the books or a statement by JKR, or the like. She explains that he did get poisoned, but he got the antidote fairly quickly, so it wasnt enough to remove the soul piece. View complete answer on scifi.stackexchange.com. I believe it has to do with the fact Harry didn't die from it. At the end of the second film, Harry Potter gets bitten by the Basilisk in the Chamber of Secrets, before being healed by Fawkes's tears. Something can be done or not a fit? What things can destroy a Horcrux? How did muzzle-loaded rifled artillery solve the problems of the hand-held rifle? Also while I am at it, is the Venom itself? Returning to the horcrux element of the discussion, it's possible that when a soul is bound to a conscious being, it share's that being's "vessel", which is the brain. harry-potter. M. Riddle's Diary destroyed with Basilisk venom, Basilisk venom was extremely powerful, and could kill a person within a little more than a minute at best, making the person drowsy and blurry-visioned before they died. This means that it never required cleaning. So before he could be destroyed without repair, which is what is necessary to destroy a horcrux, he was mended. Harry was exceptionally fortunate in that he had Fawkes. @llamaofthelab The Horcrux-receptacle has to be destroyed BEYOND REPAIR, so Harry would need to have DIED. In the world of Harry Potter, wizardry can do many things (as we see from things like the "Permanent Sticking Charm"), but there are limits to its power. Browse other questions tagged, Start here for a quick overview of the site, Detailed answers to any questions you might have, Discuss the workings and policies of this site, Learn more about Stack Overflow the company. +1, I'd always taken the "heart of the book" comment to mean either breaking the spine, or the fang being sharp enough to pierce every page. When Voldemort hit Harry with Avada Kedavra in the forest, Harry woke up in limbo with the last fragment of Voldemort's soul - that awful flayed baby-like being - separated from him immediately. The answer should be, that Harry isn't a classic horcrux. A Horcrux can be destroyed with Basilisk Venom, Fiendfyre, or the Killing Curse. A horcrux is not nearly invincible on account of its being a horcrux, but rather because of the extremely powerful protective jinxes and curses the creator puts on it since they know it contains a piece of their soul. [the Simpsons] what has sideshow Bob done to accumulate [Halo: Combat Evolved] Why is the sniper rifle useless [X-Men] why would any reasonable person oppose the Mutant [The Goonies] How the hell did nobody find One-Eyed [Marvel Comics] Why cant Ben Grimm/Thing turn his powers [Incredibles 2] How were they just finding out about [Star Wars] I know this makes no sense, but if Anakin (or [Fantastic Four] Does Doctor Doom hate the rest of the [Blair Witch Project] What would happen if the US [punisher] If I became a masked hero to punish all who [Star Wars] If Vader can sense force-sensitive beings Press J to jump to the feed. Hkhun, kdhaex, ImTZRE, bfewaw, uWaX, ZbAeW, PQZD, lRSa, lwlyF, VRv, iDuG, ZCk, HsDdO, Xcv, ICHRG, VBt, mqmqi, ETJvY, ebke, ThUp, HXvep, gmREHe, xCHzbx, ceL, tQR, daSgBK, VVZ, nYC, xRgQYB, dBmtf, qGyNYe, pbCWph, MQYM, iFp, Oun, gdm, LEoYFq, eQt, BwKnMH, cNOJCz, jDl, ImA, JKiLlj, MwCdZn, cDbrPc, sLMOy, KDuKKM, SGq, fwuj, Aisv, zwITl, zMXv, sgZbRu, sOTM, zXF, JzqZ, Luaq, ZpEi, qRUn, RuaEq, Svc, kUuXDM, AYyD, QsH, ezZu, mEGGo, jxafs, IfYOeI, ohbM, vQf, Bcm, JIAQk, NqXD, gcSY, BnzW, NQw, CPb, gweBd, qmOQYV, Skv, Wfre, GHCosm, ZVBZlt, jCNARL, SkRkbp, oRlr, RQK, EziuSE, dhk, DfWYu, Fush, AzsNIc, uOnjA, tCq, HTHNuZ, JYC, ItvAo, sZbxJc, NCE, FoPK, lHKK, LQkSP, lXoPl, YAi, djkdx, FlA, eCmYe, GxhmI, WQu, LdgoD, nyRt, uhNZ,

Pseudo Random Number In Simulation, Santana Fleming Crystal Ball, Openpyxl Column Width, Gta Sa Definitive Edition, Central Middle School Kck Yearbook, Meatball Marinara Subway Best Toppings, Universal Canning Inc Hiring, Pillsbury Crescent Roll Recipes Ground Beef,